Rekeying vs. Replacing Locks: Making the Right Security Choice for Your Home

Why Lock Changes Matter More Than You Think

Home security is more than just alarms and cameras-it starts at your front door. Whether you've just moved in, lost a set of keys, or experienced a break-in, securing your property should be a top priority. But when it comes to protecting your home, should you rekey your locks or replace them entirely?

Many homeowners find themselves puzzled by this choice. Each option offers distinct advantages depending on the situation. This guide by Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney aims to help you understand the difference between rekeying and replacing your locks, so you can choose the right solution for your peace of mind.

What Does Rekeying a Lock Involve?

Rekeying a lock means changing the internal pins and tumblers inside the lock cylinder so that it works with a new key, while the physical lock remains the same. This process is a smart and cost-effective way to enhance security without replacing the entire lock hardware.

The locksmith removes the lock from the door, rearranges the pins in the cylinder, and provides you with a new key that fits the updated configuration. Once done, all previous keys become useless-even if someone else still has them.

When Is Rekeying the Right Choice?

• After moving into a new home
• If you've lost your keys and are worried about unauthorized access
• When tenants move out of a rental property
• Following employee turnover at commercial premises
• For establishing a master key system across multiple locks

One of the biggest benefits of rekeying is that it maintains the appearance and structure of your existing locks. If your hardware is still in good condition and you're primarily concerned about who has keys, rekeying is often the ideal choice. It's also typically faster and cheaper than a full lock replacement.

Why You Might Need to Replace Your Locks

Replacing locks involves removing the entire lock mechanism and installing a new one. This approach provides a fresh start for your home security and allows you to upgrade to more advanced locking systems.

Unlike rekeying, which only alters the key access, replacing locks gives you the opportunity to enhance the quality and features of your door hardware-ideal for boosting both aesthetics and functionality.

When Lock Replacement Makes Sense

• When your locks are old, damaged, or corroded
• If you're upgrading to smart locks or high-security systems
• After a break-in or attempted burglary
• To match your new home décor or hardware finishes
• If your existing locks are no longer supported or secure

While replacing locks is more expensive than rekeying, it offers a higher level of security, especially when you upgrade to ANSI Grade 1 or 2 locks or smart access systems. For example, if your property has been burglarized, it's often recommended by authorities such as The Metropolitan Police to consider full hardware replacements as part of your recovery plan.

Ultimately, lock replacement is a strategic move when you're looking to modernize your home's security infrastructure and eliminate any doubts about past vulnerabilities.

Comparing the Costs: Rekeying vs. Replacing Locks

Cost plays a significant role when choosing between rekeying and replacing locks. Understanding what each option involves can help you make a smart financial decision without compromising security.

How Much Does Rekeying Cost?

Rekeying is generally the more affordable option. Most professional locksmiths charge a flat fee per lock or offer a bundled rate for multiple locks. The cost usually includes labor and the new keys. On average, rekeying can cost between £15-£40 per lock, depending on complexity and the type of lock.

How Much Does Lock Replacement Cost?

Replacing locks involves purchasing entirely new hardware, which makes it more expensive. Standard locks can cost anywhere from £30-£100 per unit, while high-security or smart locks can exceed £200 each. On top of that, locksmith installation fees add to the overall expense.

Value vs. Investment

If your current locks are in good shape and you simply need to restrict access, rekeying offers great value for money. However, if your locks are outdated or pose a security risk, replacing them is a worthwhile investment that may prevent greater costs in the event of a break-in.

For property managers or landlords, rekeying is often the preferred route between tenants. On the other hand, upgrading locks can add value to your home and peace of mind for new homeowners.

 

 

How Each Option Affects Your Home Security

When deciding between rekeying or replacing your locks, one of the most important factors to consider is how each choice impacts the security of your home. While both enhance safety, they do so in different ways.

Does Rekeying Improve Security?

Yes-especially if you're unsure who might have a copy of your old keys. Rekeying makes all previous keys useless, which is crucial after a move, a lost key, or any situation where key control has been compromised. However, the physical integrity of the lock remains unchanged. If the lock is old or easy to pick, rekeying won't improve its strength.

Security Advantages of Replacing Locks

Replacing your locks allows you to select modern, high-security models that offer superior resistance to picking, bumping, or drilling. You can also opt for smart locks with access logs, auto-lock features, and remote control, which rekeying cannot provide. This is particularly recommended by local safety advisories like the Secured by Design police initiative for maximum home protection.

When to Prioritize Each Option

• Rekeying is ideal if your locks are secure and you just want to revoke old key access.
• Replacing is better if your locks are outdated, easily bypassed, or damaged.

Think about your long-term security goals. If you're in doubt, a quick consultation with Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney can help you make the right call based on your specific needs and concerns.

Which Option Saves Time and Hassle?

Time and convenience are often overlooked factors when choosing between rekeying and replacing locks. However, the disruption caused by either process can influence your decision-especially if you're managing a busy schedule or multiple properties.

Time Efficiency of Rekeying

Rekeying is typically faster and less invasive. A professional locksmith can rekey a standard residential lock in just 10-20 minutes. There's no need to remove or modify the door hardware, making it a quick fix that minimizes interruption.

Lock Replacement Takes More Effort

Replacing a lock, especially with a different brand or style, can take longer. It might require drilling new holes or aligning strike plates, which adds to the time and complexity. Replacing several locks across a property could take hours or even a full day, depending on the setup.

DIY or Hire a Pro?

Basic rekeying kits are available for some brands, but DIY jobs risk improper installation, especially for those unfamiliar with lock mechanics. Replacing locks also demands precision-especially when upgrading to smart systems. Hiring a certified locksmith, like those at Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney, ensures the job is done right the first time, with no stress or guesswork.

Style and Functionality: Beyond Just Security

Homeowners often forget that locks aren't just about function-they're also a part of your home's appearance. Whether you're rekeying or replacing, it's worth considering how your choice will affect the style and functionality of your entryways.

Rekeying Keeps the Look Consistent

If you're happy with how your locks look, rekeying is the perfect solution. It keeps all the external hardware intact, which is especially helpful if your locks match other fixtures or have a specific finish you want to preserve. It's an invisible change that doesn't disrupt your home's design.

Replacing Opens Doors to New Features

Lock replacement allows for aesthetic upgrades and functional enhancements. Want all your exterior doors to match with sleek matte black or satin nickel finishes? Want to switch to keyless entry or fingerprint scanners? Replacing your locks gives you that flexibility.

Enhancing Functionality

Modern locks offer features such as:

• Smartphone connectivity and remote access
• Auto-lock timers
• Custom access codes for family or visitors
• Weather-resistant finishes for external use

So, if your locks are sticking, loose, or just outdated, replacing them isn't just a security improvement-it's a style and usability upgrade, too.

How to Decide: Rekey or Replace?

If you're still torn between rekeying and replacing your locks, you're not alone. Each option serves a different purpose, and the right choice depends on your unique situation. Here's a practical guide to help you make a confident decision.

Use This Quick Checklist

• Rekey your locks if:
  • You've moved into a new home
  • Someone lost a key or didn't return theirs
  • Your locks are still in great shape
  • You need to restrict access without spending much
  • You want to match all locks to a single key
• Replace your locks if:
  • The locks are old, rusted, or hard to turn
  • You want to switch to keyless or smart locks
  • There was a break-in or attempted forced entry
  • You're remodeling and want a hardware update
  • You're upgrading to high-security standards

Real-World Scenarios

1. Scenario 1: You've just bought a flat in Hackney-rekeying is quick and protects you from previous owners' keys.
2. Scenario 2: Your rental unit had a recent break-in-replacing locks is necessary for safety and peace of mind.
3. Scenario 3: You want to give your home a fresh, modern look-new lock sets can instantly elevate curb appeal.

Still unsure? Call Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney at 020 8150 6248 for a fast, honest assessment of your situation. Our expert locksmiths are always ready to help you make the right call.

Why Professional Help Makes All the Difference

Whether you choose to rekey or replace your locks, the quality of the work matters just as much as the choice itself. That's where professional locksmiths come in.

The Value of Experience and Certification

Locksmithing isn't just about having the right tools-it's about knowing the intricacies of different lock types, security grades, and installation techniques. Hiring a certified locksmith ensures that your locks will function properly, securely, and in compliance with current standards.

What Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney Offers

• Fast and professional lock rekeying services
• Full lock replacements including smart and high-security options
• Emergency lockout assistance 24/7
• Security consultations to assess your home or business risks

Based in the heart of Hackney, we're proud to serve homeowners, landlords, and business owners with affordable, reliable locksmith services. Whether you're upgrading for style, convenience, or security, we make sure your locks meet your goals.

Get peace of mind from professionals you can trust-visit our website or call us anytime at 020 8150 6248.

 

Answers to Your Most Common Questions

What is the difference between rekeying and replacing a lock?

Rekeying changes the internal pins of the lock so that it works with a new key, while the existing lock hardware remains in place. Replacing a lock involves removing the entire lock and installing a brand-new one, often with different features or improved security.

Is it cheaper to rekey or replace locks?

Rekeying is usually cheaper than replacing locks because it involves fewer materials and less labor. If your locks are in good condition and your main concern is key control, rekeying offers a cost-effective solution.

How often should I change or rekey my locks?

You should rekey your locks whenever you move into a new home, lose a key, or experience a security breach. Lock replacement is recommended when your current locks are outdated or show signs of wear and tear.

Can I rekey my locks myself?

DIY rekeying kits are available for some lock brands, but they require time, tools, and precision. If done incorrectly, it could compromise your security. For best results, it's advised to hire a professional locksmith like Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney.

Does rekeying a lock make it less secure?

No, rekeying doesn't reduce a lock's security if done correctly. However, it won't improve the mechanical strength of the lock. If you're looking for added protection, especially against picking or drilling, consider upgrading to high-security locks instead.

When should I consider replacing my locks instead of rekeying?

You should replace your locks if they're old, damaged, or not functioning properly. It's also a smart move if you want to upgrade to a new style or smart lock system for added convenience and security.

 

Make the Right Choice for Your Security

Choosing between rekeying and replacing your locks isn't always easy, but it doesn't have to be complicated. If your locks are in good condition and your concern is key control, rekeying offers an affordable and fast fix. On the other hand, if your locks are outdated, damaged, or you want the benefits of modern technology, lock replacement is a smart investment in your home's safety.

Every situation is different, and your decision should be based on your security needs, budget, and future plans. For expert guidance, you can rely on the licensed professionals at Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney.

We're here to help you secure what matters most-whether that means rekeying, replacing, or upgrading to smart access systems. Call us now at 020 8150 6248 or visit our website to schedule your service today.

Your peace of mind is just one call away. Don't wait until it's too late-secure your home with Kyox Locksmiths of Hackney.

 

<<< Back to Blog